454 MAIN STREET, SAFETY HARBOR, FL, 34695

We are proud to exclusively market for sale Harbor Inn on Main, a rare generational asset located in the heart of one of America's most celebrated small towns. With 155 feet of frontage on vibrant Main Street—recently ranked #10 Best Main Street in the U.S. and #5 Best Small Town in the South by USA Today—this mixed-use property offers unmatched charm, versatility, and income potential. Built in 1918 and meticulously maintained, the property features 9,605 SF under roof and 2,599 SF of balcony space. Zoned Main Street Marketplace (MSM), this historic gem supports a wide variety of permitted uses including retail, multi-family, office, hospitality, and entertainment. Currently operating as a hybrid LTR/STR top-rated Airbnb Superhost with (8) turnkey apartment units—(6) one-bedrooms and (2) studios—each with full kitchens and baths. This income-generating property is perfect for investors or owner-occupiers. An opportunity also exists to expand with a 9th additional unit or owner/manager’s suite. The ground-floor retail space is elevated above street level and flooded with natural light, offering excellent visibility and a welcoming Main Street presence. Total retail square footage is equal to 2,983 SF and is currently rented month to month offering flexibility for an owner operator to occupy or generate longer term income. Recent capital improvements include a new roof (2020) on the primary building and new HVAC with ductwork (2023) in the retail space. Additional highlights: 14 private parking spaces, Garage/storage space, Located in Flood Zone X, Just blocks from the iconic Safety Harbor Spa, Two majestic “Great Oaks” on site, Steps away from the lively Third Friday Street Festival—a monthly downtown celebration of music, art, food, and community. This is more than a property—it’s a piece of Safety Harbor history with modern upside. Contact us today for details or to schedule a private tour.

Income and lease details aren’t published in the MLS for this listing. Ask for the offering memorandum and rent roll to run cap rate, NOI and cash-on-cash.

The most comparable commercial properties that changed hands nearby. No two are identical — ask us for a full comparative analysis.

$1,800,000

28384 US HIGHWAY 19 N

6,000 sqft · $300/sqft · Sold Jan 15, 2026

$36,000

123 2ND AVENUE S

1,260 sqft · $29/sqft · Sold May 15, 2026

$520,000

600 SAINT PETERSBURG DR E

980 sqft · $531/sqft · Sold Oct 10, 2025

Pick a day that works — this goes straight to David's phone and CRM.

Keep looking

Similar properties nearby

$3,895,000

515 2ND STREET N, SAFETY HARBOR

Multi Family (5+) · 1,041 sqft